The Performance of Thoughtfulness

Culture & personalpersonal essayOriginal on Substack

A good essay is like a zip file.

It is an exercise in compressing ideas to avoid repetition, and preserve reasoning so the reader can unpack them later.

This is not always at odds with fluency - not all good ideas need to come in bulletized forms. Great paragraphs can connect ideas far better than a list of conclusions. I suspect there’s research on this.

But in the age of short attention spans, something of Gilgameshian proportions that is polished and plausible has a far greater chance of being “approved” without examination or understanding.

We privately bookmark promising essays to return to because it instantly make us feel good about ourselves - irrespective of whether we actually do.

We aspire to be people who think deeply.

But the tragedy of social media is that it criminally increases the gap between publicly endorsing thoughtfulness - through likes and retweets - vs actually practicing it.

Originally posted on X.