OpenAI’s dismissal of India’s copyright lawsuit as a “jurisdictional mismatch” reveals a fatal blind spot — India’s case isn’t about payments. It’s about dismantling the neocolonial data economy that fuels AI.
OpenAI’s defense hinges on two colonial era tactics: extraction, and the dismissal of local governance. By scraping India’s newspapers, books, and films without payment, it replicates the logic of empires that mined resources but left colonies impoverished. When Indian publishers protested, OpenAI shrugged: “Your laws don’t apply to us.” Sound familiar?
India’s 1.4 billion people represent the largest AI user base outside China — a country that has recently proven it can outpace Silicon Valley. If courts rule against OpenAI, they will set a legal precedent: AI trained on a nation’s culture must pay tribute to its laws.
Brazil is drafting similar legislation for Portuguese-language data. Kenya's AI regulation has already landed. The Global South isn’t just suing, it’s unionizing.
ChatGPT’s ability to summarize The Indian Express’s investigations verbatim doesn’t democratize: it plagiarizes, diverting readers, ad revenue, and trust from the outlets that fund reporting. Meanwhile, U.S. publishers like The New York Times secure licensing deals. Why is Indian content “free” but western journalism worthy of payment?
The answer lies in what we might term "algorithmic imperialism" — a system where AI mimics the Global South’s voice, stories, and labor, but funnels profits and control back to Silicon Valley. When ChatGPT generates Hindi poetry using centuries-old Indian texts, it monetizes a legacy OpenAI never paid to learn.
India’s lawsuit forces a reckoning: Should OpenAI’s Hindi outputs, trained on Indian texts, be governed by California’s “fair use”, or New Delhi’s copyright courts?
This isn’t just about copyright. It’s about who gets to shape the mind of AGI.
If India wins, it proves data isn’t the new “oil.” It’s the new land, and the Global South is reclaiming it.
--
If you have any questions or thoughts, don't hesitate to reach out. You can find me as @viksit on Twitter.